Manuscript title:
Reviewer number: E- Mailed to Reviewer:
e-Press,
Behavioral
Change
MANUSCRIPT REVIEW FORM
Please
return this form (and manuscript, if it contains your comments) by FAX (410) 383-4110
or email within three weeks of receipt.
We very much appreciate your valuable expertise.
Please
evaluate this manuscript bearing in mind the following considerations:
4
Importance of
subject to the health and welfare of
poor and underserved communities
Primarily and to the underserved and at-risk
communities as well as the general community regarding concerns around primary
and secondary preventions of disease and health promotion
4 Appropriateness of study design (for research papers)
4 Strength of
evidence supporting conclusions
4 Clarity
Please
complete each of the following five sections:
1. Findings c New, major importance
c Confirmatory,
major importance
c New,
minor importance
c Confirmatory,
minor importance
c Little
value
2. Validity c Valid
c Weak in
some aspects (Please explain below)
c Invalid (Please
explain below)
c Not
applicable
3. Completeness c No information gaps
c Minor
gaps (Please explain below)
c Significant
gaps (Please explain below)
4. Recommendation c Accept as is or with minor revision
c Accept
after major revision providing reviewer's comments are satisfied
c Reconsider
after major revision
c Reject
5. Remarks: Please record your remarks on additional
sheets as necessary. We would rather
receive comments that are overly lengthy than overly brief. Your comment sheet will be forwarded to the
author(s); if you wish to direct comments to the editor, please use a cover
letter. You may write additional
detailed comments on the manuscript if you wish.
In reaching a
decision, the editor considers the relevance of the paper, reader interest, and
recommendations from you and at least one other reviewer.
Note: The
above relates to articles, monographs, books and
any other format of publishable material(s).
